As the 2025 changes to the Security Industry Authority (SIA) licence renewal process draw closer, security professionals across the UK are faced with important decisions about their career paths. For many, the choice between renewing their Door Supervisor licence or switching to a Security Guard licence is a crucial one. Both roles are integral to maintaining safety and security in a variety of settings, but they come with different responsibilities, training requirements, and career implications. This article will explore the key differences between these two roles and help you determine which SIA licence renewal path is best for you.
Understanding the Roles: Door Supervisor vs Security Guard
Before diving into the specifics of the licence renewal process, it’s important to understand the fundamental differences between a Door Supervisor and a Security Guard. While both roles involve safeguarding people, property, and premises, the nature of their work, their environments, and their challenges can differ significantly.
Door Supervisor: Protecting Licensed Premises
A Door Supervisor is typically employed in environments where alcohol is sold or where regulated entertainment takes place, such as pubs, nightclubs, and music venues. The primary responsibilities of a Door Supervisor include:
-
- Controlling entry: Ensuring that only those who are permitted to enter do so, which often involves checking IDs, managing guest lists, and refusing entry to individuals who are intoxicated or behaving disruptively.
-
- Managing crowds: Handling large groups of people, maintaining order, and preventing overcrowding.
-
- Conflict resolution: De-escalating situations that could lead to violence, aggression, or disorder.
-
- Conducting searches: Performing searches of individuals to prevent illegal items, such as weapons or drugs, from entering the premises.
Given the nature of these responsibilities, Door Supervisors must be skilled in managing potentially volatile situations, often under the influence of alcohol or in crowded environments. Their work is critical to maintaining a safe and secure atmosphere for patrons and staff.
Security Guard: A Broader Scope of Protection
Security Guards, on the other hand, work in a wider variety of settings, including retail stores, office buildings, construction sites, and hospitals. Their responsibilities are diverse and can include:
-
- Patrolling premises: Conduct regular checks to detect unauthorised access, theft, or damage.
-
- Monitoring surveillance systems: Observing CCTV footage to identify suspicious activity and responding accordingly.
-
- Access control: Regulating who enters and exits a building or site, often involving the use of security systems such as key cards or biometric scanners.
-
- Emergency response: Acting quickly in the event of an incident, whether it be a fire, medical emergency, or security breach.
-
- Reporting and record-keeping: Documenting incidents, maintaining logs, and communicating with management or law enforcement as needed.
Security Guards often work in environments that are less prone to sudden, intense conflicts than those managed by Door Supervisors. However, their role is no less important, as they provide essential protection for a wide range of properties and individuals.
The 2025 SIA Licence Renewal Process
Starting from 1 April 2025, all Door Supervisors and Security Guards will be required to complete a refresher qualification before renewing their licences. This training ensures that all security personnel remain up-to-date with the latest industry practices, legal requirements, and technology.
To enrol in the refresher training, you must first have a valid Emergency First Aid at Work (EFAW) qualification or an equivalent. This prerequisite underscores the importance of first aid skills in the security industry, where the ability to respond to emergencies can be a matter of life and death.
Choosing Your Path: Door Supervisor or Security Guard?
When deciding whether to renew your Door Supervisor licence or switch to a Security Guard licence, several factors should be considered:
1. Nature of Your Current Role
The most obvious factor is the nature of your current job. If you are currently employed as a Door Supervisor and your work involves managing entry to licensed premises, handling crowds, and dealing with potentially aggressive individuals, renewing your Door Supervisor licence is likely the best choice. This will allow you to continue working in environments where these skills are essential.
On the other hand, if your role involves guarding premises, monitoring CCTV, or providing security in a more static or patrol-based capacity, you might consider switching to a Security Guard licence. This option may also be appealing if you are looking for a change in your work environment or if your current role is shifting away from the responsibilities typically associated with a Door Supervisor.
2. Training and Cost Considerations
The refresher training for a Door Supervisor licence is generally more extensive than that for a Security Guard licence. This reflects the additional skills required for managing licensed premises and handling potentially volatile situations. Consequently, the Door Supervisor refresher training may be more expensive and time-consuming.
If cost and time are significant considerations for you, switching to a Security Guard licence might be the more practical option. The Security Guard refresher training is usually shorter and less costly, making it an attractive alternative for those who do not need the additional skills covered in the Door Supervisor course.
3. Career Aspirations
Your long-term career goals should also influence your decision. If you aspire to work in high-risk environments, such as nightclubs, large event venues, or other locations where crowd management and conflict resolution are critical, maintaining your Door Supervisor licence will keep those opportunities open.
Conversely, if you are looking to broaden your career options and potentially move into roles that involve more surveillance, access control, or emergency response, a Security Guard licence might be more appropriate. This licence can open doors to a wider range of job opportunities across various sectors.
4. Legal and Regulatory Changes
The SIA has made it clear that keeping up with legal and regulatory changes is a key reason for the upcoming licence renewal requirements. If you work in a heavily regulated environment, such as a licensed premises, staying informed about these changes is particularly important. The Door Supervisor refresher course will cover the most relevant updates and ensure that you remain compliant.
For those in more general security roles, the Security Guard refresher training will still cover essential legal updates, but it may be less focused on the specific challenges faced by Door Supervisors.
The Practicalities of Switching Licences
If you decide to switch from a Door Supervisor to a Security Guard licence, you will need to complete the Security Guard refresher training and apply for the new licence. This process is relatively straightforward, but it is important to consider the timing. You must ensure that your first aid qualification is up-to-date and that you complete the necessary training before your current licence expires.
Switching to a Security Guard licence can be a strategic move if your current job does not require the additional skills associated with Door Supervision. It can also be beneficial if you are looking to reduce training costs or transition to a different type of security work.
Making an Informed Decision
The decision between renewing your Door Supervisor licence or switching to a Security Guard licence is a significant one, with implications for your career, training requirements, and daily responsibilities. By carefully considering the nature of your current role, the cost and time involved in training, your long-term career goals, and the legal requirements of your job, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your professional aspirations.
Remember that both roles are vital to the safety and security of the public, and whichever path you choose, you will be contributing to a safer environment for everyone. As the 2025 SIA licence renewal deadline approaches, take the time to evaluate your options and plan your next steps accordingly. With the right preparation, you can continue to thrive in your security career, whether as a Door Supervisor or a Security Guard.
